Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more

Restoring critical thinking and common sense to the American Left

The Democratic Party lost its way with many Americans

David Cycleback

Jan 29

READ IN APP

The American Political Landscape: A Centrist Majority

Most Americans lean toward the political center, favoring cooperation, compromise, and practical solutions over rigid ideological extremes. The increasing hyperpartisanship end extremism in the Democratic and Republican parties is largely fueled by political elites and systemic issues like gerrymandering, rather than the broader public or everyday party members.

David Cycleback: Big Ideas is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Subscribed

Historically, the American Left was seen as a defender of reason, science, and the concerns of ordinary people. The Democratic Party prided itself on critical thinking, pragmatic policymaking, intellectual discourse, and its commitment to the working class. However, in recent years, factions within the Left have strayed far from this tradition. Vocal extremist groups within the left—too often enabled or tolerated by the Democratic Party—have alienated voters, eroded public trust, and damaged the party’s credibility. To restore its credibility, the Left must reject ideological rigidity, censorship, and extremism while championing evidence-based policies and intellectual diversity.

Key Challenges Facing the American Left

Perceptions of Elitism and Detachment

The recent Democratic Party is often criticized for being dominated by elites who are out of touch with the concerns of working-class and rural Americans. Progressive discourse frequently relies on academic jargon, elite urban voices, and abstract ivory tower theories, sidelining practical, real-world issues and the concerns of everyday Americans.

Example: The term Latinx, intended to promote inclusivity, is widely rejected by Latino communities but remains prominent in progressive rhetoric, reinforcing the perception of elitism and arrogance.

Cultural Disconnects: Attempts to align with celebrity and pop culture—like Vice President Kamala Harris’s appearances with wealthy celebrities— came across as superficial and gimmicky, furthering perceptions of elitism rather than extending the party’s appeal to everyday people. After the 2024 elections, voters concerned about higher grocery prices and being unable to purchase a first home said Beyonce and Taylor Swift campaign concerts were, at best, irrelevant to their needs.

Kamala Harris's campaign associating itself with celebrity pop culture fell flat with many working-class and poor Americans

Dismissing and Attacking the Working Class:Urban cultural elites dismissing working-class, rural Americans and Republicans as ignorant, backward, or racist alienates many and drives them further from the Left.

One lifelong Democrat recently shared the following:

This growing detachment—coupled with the increasing focus on urban, highly educated constituencies—has pushed many working-class and rural voters, including minorities, to seek alternative political options.

The Rejection of Common Sense

When ideology takes precedence over simple common sense and observable reality, the Left’s credibility and effectiveness are undermined.

Policy Missteps:

• Crime & Public Safety: Progressive policies like decriminalizing public drug use and adopting lenient approaches to petty theft such as shoplifting have contributed to rising crime and overdose deaths in cities like San Francisco and Portland, eroding public trust. Most Americans could have predicted the disastrous results.

• Education & Equity: Eliminating advanced math programs in high schools to promote equity undermines meritocracy and alienates those who value academic achievement.

• Fighting Racism with Racism: Simplistically framing any and all disparities as products of racism or sexism is clearly false, and overlooks other factors like class and geography.

• Biological Reality & Fairness: Denying the existence of biological differences between sexes, especially in sports and feminist concerns, not only defies common sense but alienates moderates and fuels perceptions that the Left is disconnected from reality.

• Border Policy: Lax immigration enforcement and open-border rhetoric have strained resources and raised concerns among traditionally Democratic constituencies. The inability to tackle massive illegal immigration and dismissing those who raised concerns was one of the key reasons for voters switching from Democrat to Republican during the 2024 campaign.

Cultural Narratives and Extreme Rhetoric

• Undermining Objectivity: Some progressive postmodernist perspectives argue that science, logic, and reason are inherently tied to racial or cultural constructs, framing them as oppressive. These claims not only lack credibility but also undermine universally valued principles that transcend identity politics.

• Identity Over Ideas: The notion that a person's identity determines the legitimacy of their opinions fosters division rather than meaningful dialogue. Most Americans believe in evaluating individuals based on character, merit, and the substance of their ideas rather than immutable characteristics like race or gender.

• Victimhood Culture: Glorifying oppression as a form of moral superiority is counterproductive and widely rejected by most Americans. Teaching people that they are inherently and eternally victims is developmentally backward.

Prioritizing Politics Over Science and Facts

The Left has long positioned itself as the party of science and critical thinking. However, its credibility has been undermined by those who dismiss or obscure inconvenient realities to align with political narratives.

Examples of Misdirected Priorities:

• COVID-19 and the Wuhan Lab Theory: Early discussions about the virus’s potential origins in a Wuhan lab were dismissed by Democratic leaders and left-leaning media as conspiratorial, xenophobic, and racist. Yet, this theory is now widely considered plausible, demonstrating the risks of politicizing scientific inquiry.

• Biden’s Cognitive Health: Concerns over President Joe Biden’s clearly observable cognitive decline were largely ignored or suppressed, with instances of public confusion dismissed as partisan attacks. This suppression has deeply eroded public trust in the Democratic Party.

• Politically Partisan Organizations: Once-respected scientific institutions—including elite universities, the ACLU, and publications like Scientific American and Nature—are increasingly seen as prioritizing progressive ideology over objective research. This shift has damaged trust in institutions that are supposed to uphold unbiased inquiry, with some now viewing these organizations as partisan shills rather than scientific.

• Silencing Inconvenient Truths: Public experts such as Democratic Party data analyst David Shor and Harvard economist Roland Fryer, who presented evidence-based findings that challenged dominant leftist narratives, faced intense backlash. This reinforces the perception that ideological conformity is valued over truth, further weakening the Left’s credibility in the realm of science and reason.

Cancel Culture, Ad Hominem Attacks, and Circular Firing Squads

Critical thinking, science, and pragmatism thrive on open debate, yet cancel culture has become a defining characteristic of the progressive Left. Those who challenge the dominant narrative are often quickly labeled as “bigoted” or “right-wing.” When the Left resorts to ad hominem attacks, calling those with alternative viewpoints racist or uninformed, it weakens their credibility and alienates moderates who want to engage in meaningful discussion. The progressive Left’s tendency to vilify anyone deemed “impure” through circular firing squads only reinforces the perception of ideological zealotry.

Overreactions, such as labeling Trump a Nazi, describing Republicans as evil, or absurdly accusing Elon Musk of making a Nazi salute, give the Left an appearance of being irrational, prone to hysteria, and unreasonably extreme.

The ideas may originate from the extremes, but the Democratic Party and left press have enabled and too often embraced them

This includes adopting progressive jargon, engaging in ideological policing, and reflexively dismissing critics—including those within the Left—who question critical race theory, open-border policies, or so-called "woke" ideologies.

In the United States, trust in the press has now fallen below that of Congress, reflecting widespread skepticism toward media objectivity and credibility.

A Path Forward: Restoring Credibility

Focus on Practical SolutionsTackle issues like crime, homelessness, and drug use with evidence-based, pragmatic policies. Balance equity initiatives with meritocracy to promote fairness while maintaining excellence.

Foster Open Debate and Intellectual DiversityEncourage dialogue on challenging issues, such as gender policies in sports or the origins of COVID-19. Embracing rather than attacking diverse viewpoints fosters trust and strengthens credibility.

Reframe Social Justice EffortsApproach race, class, and identity issues with nuance and common sense, focusing on shared values and unity rather than division. Promote efforts that build bridges, not walls.

Improve MessagingCommunicate clearly and directly, focusing on practical solutions that appeal to a broad audience. Avoid polarizing rhetoric like “Defund the Police” which alienates moderates and stifles meaningful conversation. Rather than academic jargon, speak in the language that the everyday American public uses.

Reject Ideological Rigidity and ExtremismPush back against extremist factions and fringe ideas, prioritizing a centrist, pragmatic approach that serves diverse communities. This strategy will help broaden appeal and restore trust.

Honestly listen to Diverse PerspectivesEngage with people from outside the political bubble, especially conservatives, rural Americans, and working-class voters, to better understand their concerns.

The Media’s RoleThe mainstream press must prioritize unbiased, fact-based reporting. Biased narratives only deepen divisions and distort public opinion.

.

Conclusion

The American Left risks losing its identity as the champion of reason, science, and pragmatism. By returning to its core principles—critical thinking, evidence-based policymaking, fairness, and honesty—it can rebuild trust and reconnect with the broader electorate. To meet the challenges ahead, the Left must embrace practical solutions, intellectual humility, and open dialogue, and explicitly reject the fringe extremists and elitists within the Left.